The Airbnb Host's Evidence Pack: What to Collect in 2025

When an Airbnb stay goes wrong, the difference between winning a dispute and losing hundreds of dollars often comes down to one thing: the quality of your evidence. Relying on your word against a guest's is a losing game. To protect your property and your business, you need to think like a detective, and that means collecting irrefutable proof.

Many hosts wait until a problem occurs to start gathering evidence, but by then, it's often too late. The most successful hosts build evidence collection directly into their operational workflow. This guide outlines the essential items you need in your "Evidence Pack" to confidently handle any claim that comes your way.

1. The Foundation: Timestamped Photos & Videos

This is the most critical component of your evidence kit. Digital proof is powerful, but only if it can be verified.

• Pre-Stay Photos (The "Before"): Within 24 hours of a guest's check-in, take a comprehensive set of photos of your property. Go room by room and capture everything. Don't just take wide shots; photograph details like the tops of dressers, the inside of the oven, and the condition of remote controls.
• Post-Stay Photos (The "After"): As soon as possible after a guest checks out, repeat the process. If you find damage, photograph it from multiple angles, including a wide shot to show its location and close-ups to show the severity.
• Video Walk-throughs: A continuous video walk-through before and after a stay can be even more compelling than photos, as it's harder to dispute the timeline.
• How to Timestamp: Most modern smartphones automatically embed date and time data (EXIF data) into photos. For extra security, you can use an app that visibly overlays the date and time on the image itself.

Pro Tip: When submitting photos to Airbnb, mention that they are timestamped. For example: "Please see the attached timestamped photo, taken at 9:15 AM on Oct 6, 2025, showing the broken lamp."

2. The Narrative: Airbnb Message Threads

All communication with guests should happen on the Airbnb platform. This creates an official, unalterable record that Airbnb support can easily review.

• Screenshot Everything Important: Don't just rely on the message history. Screenshot key conversations, especially those where:
  • A guest admits to an issue or accident.
  • You inform a guest of a house rule violation.
  • A guest makes an unreasonable demand.
  • A guest's story changes.
• Why Screenshots?: While Airbnb can see the messages, providing screenshots in your initial report makes the support agent's job easier. Highlight the key messages to guide their attention. This is especially important if you suspect a guest might be trying to engage in review extortion.

3. The Financials: Invoices and Receipts

If you're making a claim for damage or extra services, you must prove the monetary loss.

• Repair Quotes: Get a formal quote or invoice from a professional contractor or repair service. A handwritten note with a number on it is not enough.
• Replacement Costs: If an item is destroyed, find a link to an identical or very similar item online. A screenshot of a retail product page showing the price is excellent evidence.
• Extra Cleaning Fees: Document the need for extra cleaning with photos of the mess. Then, provide an invoice from your cleaning service that specifically details the extra time or services required.

4. The Rules: House Rules & Listing Description

Your house rules are your contract with the guest. When a guest books, they agree to abide by them.

• Screenshot Your Rules: Keep a dated screenshot of your house rules as they appeared at the time of the booking.
• Reference Specific Rules: When reporting a violation, don't just say the guest broke the rules. Quote the exact rule they broke. For example: "The guest violated our 'No Smoking' policy, as stated in our house rules."
• Align with Your Listing: Ensure your listing description accurately sets expectations. This can be crucial in preventing complaints before they even happen, which is always the best strategy. Learn more about preventing bad reviews on Airbnb.

5. The Witnesses: Third-Party Documentation

Sometimes, you need external validation for your claim.

• Police Reports: For any situation involving theft, vandalism, or illegal activity, a police report is non-negotiable. It is one of the strongest forms of evidence you can provide.
• Noise Complaints: If you have a noise-monitoring device (like Minut or NoiseAware), screenshots of the decibel level alerts are powerful proof. Ensure you disclose the presence of these devices in your listing.
• Neighbor Statements: While harder to formalize, a written statement from a neighbor who witnessed a party or other disturbance can add weight to your claim.

Citing the Source: Airbnb Help Center

Airbnb's own policies are your best friend. Familiarize yourself with the Host damage protection terms. When you make a claim, referencing the specific policy you believe the guest has violated shows that you are an informed and professional host.

FAQ: Building Your Evidence Pack

1. How long should I keep evidence after a stay?

Keep all photos and documentation for at least 60 days after a stay concludes. This covers the 14-day review window and allows ample time for any post-stay issues to surface.

2. Is it my word against theirs if they deny everything?

This is why you collect evidence. Without proof, it is your word against theirs, and Airbnb will often side with the guest. With a folder full of timestamped photos, message screenshots, and invoices, it's no longer a matter of opinion.

3. What if the damage is minor? Is it still worth reporting?

Even minor damage should be documented with photos. You may choose not to file a claim for a small scuff mark, but having a record is useful. If you notice a pattern of minor damage from multiple guests, it might indicate a need to change something in your setup.

4. Can I record my guests?

You absolutely cannot record guests in private spaces like bedrooms or bathrooms. Security cameras and noise monitoring devices are permissible in common areas and outside the property, but they must be disclosed in your listing before a guest books. Failure to disclose can get you banned from the platform.

---

The Bottom Line: Be Prepared, Not Paranoid

Building an evidence pack isn't about expecting the worst from every guest. It's about running a professional business. By integrating these documentation steps into your routine, you create a safety net. Most of the time, you'll never need it. But when you do, it will be the most valuable asset you have.